Get the app
Consulting
Consulting
on
GigglyMochi
GigglyMochi
EY

New company asking for in hand offer document

Hi guys, I recently got an offer from company B. I told them I have an offer from company A and would expect a hike on that.

I even shared a redacted version of the offer I was holding with the company name, HR details etc striked out.

But they're insisting on sharing the full document, which I feel is not really necessary.

Is this a norm or is sharing the salary annexure of the in hand offer enough ?

Appreciate any suggestions.

1d ago
Jobs
One interview, 1000+ job opportunities
Take a 10-min AI interview to qualify for numerous real jobs auto-matched to your profile 🔑
+322 new users this month
FuzzyPretzel
FuzzyPretzel
Stealth1d

Don't share. It might come back to bite from both orgs. Tell them it's confidential just like the conversation they have.

Don't share. Period.

GigglyMochi
GigglyMochi
EY1d

Yeah I looked up online that HR's have good networks. Could end up in a difficult situation

ZippyBoba
ZippyBoba
Flipkart1d

Yeah , tell them if you can their offer letter too with someone else?

MagicalJellybean
MagicalJellybean
Coinbase1d

Don't share, prepare to walk away.

Tell them thar doc is confidential information

GigglyMochi
GigglyMochi
EY1d

Yes that's what I am thinking

FloatingPotato
FloatingPotato
Sapiens1d

I have always shared the full document. Never faced any issues.

GigglyMochi
GigglyMochi
EY19h

Weren't you worried about the new firm reaching out to the other company ? Worst case scenario

Discover more
Curated from across